past student commentary

http://31longroadmusicvideo10.blogspot.com/

this groups commentary was different to most other groups i saw, it started with a brief clip of there music video then the first question faded over the top before a transition to the group sitting together, this was effective in the sense that it gave the viewer a clear sense of which video and what part of it the group were talking about. The group had chosen to make the video in the style of the interview, and while they pulled this off well it didn't make the product look convincing and proffesional as most real commentaries show only the artist or artists between clips of footage, they however filmed parts of the production process (e.g final cut) which really helped to get across to the viewer what they were trying to describe and also added a proffesional look to the product.
 The group seemed confident in there speech and it sounded like they had for the most part planned it out well and were clear on what needed to be discussed without making it look as if it was being read of a script.